Criminal Law Without Punishment : : How Our Society Might Benefit From Abolishing Punitive Sanctions / / Valerij Zisman.
How can criminal punishment be morally justified? Zisman addresses this classical question in legal philosophy. He provides two maybe surprising answers to the question. First, as for a methodological claim, it argues that this question cannot be answered by philosophers and legal scholars alone. Ra...
Saved in:
Superior document: | Title is part of eBook package: De Gruyter DG Plus DeG Package 2023 Part 1 |
---|---|
VerfasserIn: | |
Place / Publishing House: | Berlin ;, Boston : : De Gruyter, , [2023] ©2023 |
Year of Publication: | 2023 |
Language: | English |
Series: | Practical Philosophy ,
25 |
Online Access: | |
Physical Description: | 1 online resource (IX, 233 p.) |
Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
Other title: | Frontmatter -- Acknowledgment -- Contents -- Part I: The Problem of Punishment -- Chapter 1 Another “New Perspective”? -- Chapter 2 Definitions, Theses, and Method -- Part II: Backward-Looking Approaches -- Introduction -- Chapter 3 Brute Retributivism -- Chapter 4 Fairness -- Chapter 5 Penance and Censure -- Chapter 6 Victims’ Rights -- Part III: Forward-Looking Approaches -- Chapter 7 Deterrence -- Part IV: Towards a Pluralistic Theory of Corrective Justice -- Chapter 8 Weaving the Patchwork Rug -- Chapter 9 Objections to Corrective Approaches to Criminal Law -- Chapter 10 Epilogue -- References -- Index of Names -- Index of Subjects |
---|---|
Summary: | How can criminal punishment be morally justified? Zisman addresses this classical question in legal philosophy. He provides two maybe surprising answers to the question. First, as for a methodological claim, it argues that this question cannot be answered by philosophers and legal scholars alone. Rather, we need to take into account research from social psychology, economy, anthropology, and so on in order to properly analyze the arguments in defense of criminal punishment. Second, the book argues that when such research is properly accounted for, none of the current attempts to justify criminal punishment succeed. But that does not imply that the state should do nothing about criminal wrongdoing. Rather, the arguments that were supposed to justify criminal punishment actually speak in favor of an alternative approach to criminal law: restitution to the victim and restorative justice. That is to say, the state should coerce offenders to provide restitution for the harm inflicted on victims, and whenever possible restorative approaches should be taken to address criminal wrongdoing. |
Format: | Mode of access: Internet via World Wide Web. |
ISBN: | 9783111027821 9783111175782 9783111319292 9783111318912 9783111319223 9783111318646 |
ISSN: | 2197-9243 ; |
DOI: | 10.1515/9783111027821 |
Access: | restricted access |
Hierarchical level: | Monograph |
Statement of Responsibility: | Valerij Zisman. |