In Search of the True Religion : : Monk Jurjī and Muslim Jurists Debating Faith and Practice / / Ayman Ibrahim, Clint Hackenburg.

• Superior document: Title is part of eBook package: De Gruyter DG Plus PP Package 2022 Part 2
• VerfasserIn: Ibrahim, Ayman,; Hackenburg, Clint,
• Place / Publishing House: Piscataway, NJ : : Gorgias Press, , [2022]; ©2022
• Year of Publication: 2022
• Language: English
• Series: Texts from Christian Late Antiquity ; 69
• Physical Description: 1 online resource (358 p.)
• Other title: Frontmatter --; Table of Contents --; Acknowledgments --; Introduction --; Jurjī the Monk and the Muslim Jurists in the Emir’s Courts --; The Monk in the Emir’s Majlis: Purpose of the Genre --; Jurjī’s Debate: Structure, Topics, and Manuscripts --; A Chronological List of the Consulted Manuscripts --; The Critical Apparatus of Our Edition --; Text and Translation --; The Dispute of Jurjī the Monk --; Section One: Comparing the Messages and Personalities of Christ and Muḥammad --; Section Two: The Beliefs of Christianity --; Section Three: An Examination of the Four Major Religions --; Bibliography
• Format: Mode of access: Internet via World Wide Web.
• ISBN: 9781463243951; 9783110767001; 9783110993899; 9783110994810; 9783110994544; 9783110994537; 9783110767100
• DOI: 10.31826/9781463243951
• Access: restricted access
• Hierarchical level: Monograph
• Statement of Responsibility: Ayman Ibrahim, Clint Hackenburg.

In the thirteenth-century, a debate transpired over the course of several days between a monk named Jurjī and several Muslims jurists in the city of Aleppo. This debate represents a careful and sophisticated example of a literary genre that Sidney Griffith calls the “monk in the emir’s majlis.” By the time of Jurjī’s debate, this literary genre had been developing among the Christians living under Islamic rule since the seventh century. Prominent examples of this genre were composed by Timothy I, Theodore Abū Qurrah, and Elias of Nisibis to name a few. During his encounter, Jurjī and his opponents discuss the entire gamut of Christian-Muslim controversy, from dietary restriction and sexual relations to the Trinity and Incarnation. Jurjī’s can be divided into three major sections: (1) Comparing the Messages and Personalities of Christ and Muḥammad; (2) The Sacraments of Christianity; and (3) An Examination of the Four Major Religions. In addition to citing scriptures in his arguments, both the Bible and the Qurʾān, Jurjī uniquely makes use of extended parables throughout his debate. Although the general tenor of the debate is friendly and respectful, Jurjī does occasionally offer rather frank criticisms of both Islam and Muḥammad. Nevertheless, in the end after triumphantly defending Christianity and systematically criticizing Islam, Jurjī is praised by the emir and marches off into the sunset toward his monastery. The immense popularity of this work is demonstrated by the sheer volume of surviving manuscripts, which number around hundred. Due to the lack of academic study of this notable work, we have decided to prepare a critical edition and translation of a once significant work among the Christians of the Middle East with the hopes of reviving its importance in the monk in the emir’s majlis genre.